In agility, and perhaps other canine sports, a dog will sometimes break away from his/her handler and go running around the course, darting this way and that, often taking some time to catch. Agility trainers call that the zoomies. They don’t like it.
A positive retriever trainer can have it happen, too. In this case, the ground the dog is covering isn’t just an enclosed agility course but could be an entire cluster of training fields where other people are training their dogs. The other trainers will say the dog is ”out of control,” and will generally believe it’s a recall problem. Field trainers don’t like the zoomies, either. Having a dog with the zoomies is a good way to get kicked out of a training group.
I don’t know much about ecollars, but I take it it’s pretty easy to stop the zoomies if the dog is wearing an ecollar. I don’t know what they did in the old days. In any case, I don’t train with physical aversives, so I’d like to discuss positive options.
Certainly one thing you can do with a positive-trained dog is to keep him/her on lead as you’re walking around, rather than letting him/her walk loose as many of the traditional trainers are doing with their dogs. An ounce of prevention and all that. You really don’t want to get kicked out of the group.
Another thing you can do is to get in a lot of training in situations where the other trainers, if there are any, are OK with you needing some time to deal with the issue. I mostly train with paid assistants, for example.
But the dog is still going to need to run in training groups at times and eventually in competition. You need to address the zoomies if your dog is subject to them. All thtee of my retrievers have been.
A case in point: As I’ve been taking Lightning thru the steps of training the double T, we reached step 6, the full T, and suddenly Lightning started getting the zoomies on almost every retrieve.
Before discussing solutions, I’d like to rule out a few things. First of all, this is not a generic recall problem that can be solved with more positive recall training. That’s not to say that my dogs have not had huge, huge amounts of recall training. They have, and it has been vital. But it’s not enough for all cases of a field retriever being unwilling to come when called. Even traditional trainers sometimes have to go out and pick up a dog who’s been trained with an ecollar.
Secondly, it is not a case of the dog wishing to make the handler feel something. The dog is not being spiteful, for example. Honestly, dogs don’t care how they’re making you feel. That’s not part of their agenda. Rather, they care how they feel.
Thirdly, it’s not going to help to get mad. This is frustrating, but it’s still a matter of developing higher reinforcement history for the behavior you want than for the behavior you don’t want. That’s a hard thing to do when the behavior you don’t want is so much fun for the dog, but luckily, the behavior you do want, retrieving, is also great fun for the dog. The scales are only tipped a little against you at this point, and you’ll be able to tip them your way with patience.
But this particular problem has no universal solution. Dogs are all different and situations are all different. What is universal is the process: making changes to your training, preferably with as few wrong turns as possible, till the dog is obtaining the reinforcement needed to perform correctly.
Here then are the steps I’ve been following to address Lightning’s current case of the zoomies.
To begin, I needed a theory of why the zoomies were Lightning’s preferred behavior in this situation. I felt it could be a combination of several factors, including:
- Theory 1. My habit of letting all my dogs, including Lightning, run around loose in fields when not training. This is a natural, wholesome behavior that lets the dogs build strength, coordination, and stamina. But it seems to be highly self-reinforcing, and perhaps that causes it to occur in inappropriate situations.
- Theory 2. The novelty of the 2” bumpers with ropes attached, especially the orange ones, since I’ve been using white bumpers with no ropes for pile work and earlier steps of the double T.
- Theory 3. Confusion about the side piles when sending to the long pile, even when I switched the side pile markers from lining poles to utility flags.
- Theory 4. Given the uncomfortable temperatures and humidity, a preference for the shady area up near the trees rather than the open sunny double T course.
- Theory 5. Boredom with pile work because, with no throw, the send out is less exciting and pleasurable.
- Theory 6. Exciting scents and features, such as ground hog mounds and a wooded area, to explore on a huge new field we’ve only trained on for a few days.
Given those theories, these are the ways I attempted to address each issue:
- Change 1. On the second day of working on the full T, I put on Lightning’s harness and a 15′ check cord before letting him out of his crate, and then walked him on lead to the double T course I had set up. I didn’t like this idea because it deprived Lightning of the exercise and exhilaration he has always gotten on training days long before this case of the zoomies cropped up, but I wanted to see if it helped. I did see improvement, but it was not the only change I was making. On subsequent days after eliminating the problem, I kept some of the other changes but let him run free again down to the course, no longer wearing a check cord, and the problem did not return. So perhaps it was helpful in the solution, but it did not appear to be too significant a factor.
- Change 2. I removed the bumpers that had ropes from the pile. In retrospect I think this was the most important change, because in one case I inadvertently included a bumper with a rope and Lightning went into the zoomies the very time he picked that bumper up from the pile. I’ve now begun using bumpers and Dokkens with ropes for our playtime games of fetch to acclimate him more to those articles, but meanwhile I’m not letting those ropes act as a barrier to our double T training. The red bumper without a rope doesn’t seem to be a problem.
- Change 3. I removed the bumpers from the side piles. That stopped those diversions at least. When I put them back in a day or two, I’ll continue to use the less conspicuous utility flags but I believe I’ll be able to keep them closer than 40y from the baseline, even with bumper piles, once Lightning is consistently running solid freebies. Having them closer to the baseline will make the work less tiring and I would guess more productive.
- Change 4. I thought the weather was a major factor but in one session, we made good progress even though worked for more than an hour. I’m still positive that it’s preferable to work in cooler temps and to keep sessions short as a rule, but the uncomfortable weather doesn’t appear to have been causing the zoomies.
- Change 5. A good friend with a great deal of dog experience has told me that Labs get bored more easily than Goldens, and since Lightning is a Lab while Lumi was and Laddie is a Golden, I may be seeing some of that here. I had been fading out gunfire and the heel and chase game, and Lightning’s performance seemed to improve when I started using them more again. I need to fade then eventually, but I don’t believe they’re distorting the goal of using the double T to train handling, and they certainly seem to add positive reinforcement to the work.
- Change 6. I didn’t introduce any change to combat the newness of the field; we’ve just kept using it. Perhaps Lightning is becoming more acclimated to it, or perhaps that wasn’t a significant factor in causing the zoomies in the first place.
Today was our fourth morning of working on the full T, twice working solo and twice with Liza assisting. Lightning had made progress each day as I experimented with the changes I had come up with, and this morning, even with no harness or check cord, he didn’t have a single incident of the zoomies over eight freebies to the long pile.
So for now that problem seems to be behind us. Tomorrow, I’ll try reintroducing bumpers at the side piles while continuing to run only freebies, and soon, we’ll start some casting, which is the whole point of the double T. We’ll address the zoomies problem again if and when it reappears.
Update: My good friend and dog expert Jody Baker sent the following excellent comment by email:
I want to add another # for you. It’s stress. It’s been pretty much proven that stress can be released by activity in all animals, including people. With dogs new concepts, proofing and ever so many other things cause stress.
What you’re working on now with Lightening is certainly a stress maker for many dogs.
It may be that you moved through the steps quicker than need be because he as catching on so fast. Maybe repeating many of them for more short sessions would have been easier on him.